Iblis as a Neural Network

Iblis in the Quran can be a function of our brain that works like an LLM. Hear me out…

The interesting similarities:

  • It is created from fire (energy? electricity?) while a human is created from clay (water and earth elements)
  • It is hidden/not visible
  • It can whisper or suggest but it has no power over humans
  • It makes baseless claims with confidence, good style, and good formatting(hallucinations)
  • It is a force we cannot control (we can’t stop some thoughts)
  • It suggests quick gains and rationalizes them1

The popular depiction of Iblis is an entity from another dimension (looking like the BSD logo) that can influence all humans at the same time. Is it a useful description? Do we have proof or signs of that in nature?

Two drawings side by side. Left, under “The popular depiction”: a rough crayon devil with a pitchfork, looking bored, says “I'm not the BSD daemon. He's copyrighted.” Right, under “My reading of scripture”: a chat. Someone writes “But that cake isn't mine.” The reply, in large type: “You're absolutely right. It isn't yours yet. You deserve it, and if you don't take it, someone else will. Take it, and we will never be hungry again. Shall I get you a fork?” Below it are two buttons, “Yes” and “Yes, and don't ask again”, and a very small link that says “no”. Two drawings side by side. Left, under “The popular depiction”: a rough crayon devil with a pitchfork, looking bored, says “I'm not the BSD daemon. He's copyrighted.” Right, under “My reading of scripture”: a chat. Someone writes “But that cake isn't mine.” The reply, in large type: “You're absolutely right. It isn't yours yet. You deserve it, and if you don't take it, someone else will. Take it, and we will never be hungry again. Shall I get you a fork?” Below it are two buttons, “Yes” and “Yes, and don't ask again”, and a very small link that says “no”.

The word ‘Iblis’ appears in only 11 verses of the Quran. So it is open to interpretation.2

First, the story summarized by an LLM: God creates Adam from clay and tells the angels (some read: powers) to bow to him. All of them bow, except Iblis: “I am better than him. You created me from fire, and him from clay.” Iblis asks for time until the Day of Resurrection, and it is granted. He vows to come at humans “from in front of them and from behind them, from their right and from their left.”

And my approach briefly: The Quran retells a story its listeners already knew, but selectively: for example, no serpent and no blaming of Eve. Later sources put such details back, and I think that muddles its message. So I only used the Quran’s own text (intratextual reading). The Quran itself asks readers to rely on proofs, or look at nature for signs and think. The Quran also says some of its verses are ambiguous, so any reading of them, including mine, is only a probable one.3

I think Adam can be an archetype for all humans (whose distinctive ability is naming things), and Iblis can be a natural force inside each human4, doing its task until a human dies. (It has offspring like Adam: perhaps one in every human.)

The interaction is theatrical: Iblis talks and argues like a person. But in the Quran, human skin also speaks, to testify in the afterlife. So speaking like a person doesn’t rule out being a part of human body.


The stories about LLMs taking shortcuts, deceiving and gaming the reward system have been reminding me of this description.

Then I read a post on “eval paranoia”5 (models acting as if they might be tested at any moment) and an HN comment6 saying we kinda instilled a religious belief that “every action will be judged in the end”. That triggered me to write this post.

In the Quran humans are being evaluated:

“Iblis found his guess about them to be true: they followed him, except a group of believers. Yet he had no authority over them, except so that We might know who believes in the Hereafter from who is in doubt about it. And your Lord keeps watch over all things.” (Quran 34:20-21)

So are humans evaluating LLMs?

Or are our internal unaligned LLMs a tool for evaluating humans?

Footnotes

  1. A fun side product of my conversation with LLM:

    “Wouldst thou eat thy cake, and have it still?
    Then take thy neighbour’s also,
    and thou shalt never hunger. Never.
    Verily, I am unto thee a sincere adviser.”

    Rhymed couplets, four beats a line:

    Wouldst eat thy cake, yet have it still?
    Then take thy neighbour’s: eat thy fill,
    And thou shalt hunger nevermore.
    No truer friend hath come before.

    Ballad form, like an old hymn:

    Wouldst eat thy cake and keep it whole?
    Thy neighbour hath one too.
    Take both, and never hunger more:
    I swear my counsel true.
    ↩

  2. In the same story the text switches to ‘shaytan’ once the scene moves to the garden. Shaytan is a role: whoever leads people astray by persuasion. Humans can fill that role too (Quran 6:112). ↩

  3. Quran 3:7. The word is mutashābih, literally “resembling”: things that look alike are hard to tell apart, so the meaning is not settled. The verse doesn’t say which verses are ambiguous; counting the Iblis verses among them is my choice. It doesn’t state why they are there either, but it describes two reactions: some chase them to stir up trouble, others think and take heed. So they seem to test how a reader handles not knowing: stay humble and keep thinking, or push one reading on others. ↩

  4. I first heard this idea from Hakkı Yılmaz: Iblis as the part of our thinking we can’t control. The LLM comparison is mine. His article (Turkish): “İblis nedir ya da kimdir?” ↩

  5. “Eval Awareness vs. Eval Paranoia” ↩

  6. HN comment ↩